The
topic for this week is that what would happen hypothetically if we
hypothetically had Illinibucks that could move you to the front of lines. If
there was such a thing there would be a number of uses, a few of which we may
have mentioned in class. There is registration.
As a fortunate person who is able to partake in a job with the football
program, I have received the advantage of being able to register early, with
the athletes. Though I have not always
jumped at the opportunity right away, I usually get all of the classes I want. If you could pay money to be moved before many
others, there would certainly be students who partake in this activity. How
would price affect this sort of action? I believe that the price would not
matter for the most part and that kids would look at it as just another fee to
get the class they want. It would be incredibly unfair to students who pay significant
portions of dollars for all the services the University provides. I suspect
that no matter what type of pricing is involved, the University of Illinois
would have a sort of lawsuit or complaining that would negatively impact the
school’s image.
Another
event or opportunity for the illinibucks would have to do with sports. People
buy vouchers or sign up for orange crush, then they wait for the opportunity to
be first to turn in their vouchers or be first in line at the assembly hall. If
they could gain an edge and save themselves inconveniences and potentially
hours of their time, you would have a number of eager participants. I can see this actually being quite effective
for organizations, like the orange crush, that are required to raise funds.
Pricing as always would seem unfair to some people but this is separate from
education (or at least that would be my argument). This would cause the biggest supporters, the
kids with too much money and the craziest of the fans to get a spot on the
court or in block I. The rest would be stuck up in C section or along the opposing
sideline. I do not believe this policy would have near the effect on football
due to the fact that the seats simply are not that much better in comparison.
On the other hand the orange crush may face certain issues. Their numbers may
decrease because students don’t see the need to be a part of orange crush when
they will end up in the upper deck with no real advantage.
Let’s
continue by going back to registration. But let’s take a look at it at a
smaller level. What about jumping ahead of the line for individual classes?
This has a very similar feel to our first example. This one has a twist that
makes it a little more interesting. By dealing with individual classes it is
not nearly as universal and is not simply adding a fee, there is an actual specific
selection process. As long as everyone has an equal amount of illini bucks and
it isn’t just one overall fee this would add an aspect that may teach students
how to manage money better. In reality all this would most likely do is cause
complete chaos in the system and make too many people angry.
In my
opinion hypothetical illinibucks are most likely meant for anger, complaining,
and scandals. It does not matter what price they are. I have gotten the classes
I desired often without use of the early registration and never have been
deeply involved in the illini fanbase.
I think you didn't quite get the meaning of the hypothetical. The Illinibucks are not real money. So Orange Crush would get anything in terms of revenue by their use. If they were real money, then why not just use real money instead? But then this looks like bribery, and a source of corruption.
ReplyDeleteIf you've ever played the board game Monopoly, then you know there is Monopoly money used just in the game and the various properties have prices. Each player gets the same allotment of Monopoly money at the beginning of the game. Even if you win the game, you are not richer outside the game.
So the question is whether you could treat some of the inconveniences students go through on Campus like a game of Monopoly, and might that make things better.
A typo in the above. It should say "Orange Crush wouldn't get anything...."
DeleteYour discussion of Orange Krush reminded me that currently there are two tiers of Orange Krush membership that is related to prices, to an extent. The All-American pledges $3.00/per three point shot, whereas the Varsity level only pledges $1.00-$1.50/three-point shot. These levels line up separately and All-American students are allowed to go into Assembly Hall first, thus getting better seats. The Varsity level does not generally get floor seats and must sit higher up. Granted, the money pledged is donated to a good cause so it is a philanthropic endeavor. Nonetheless, it is an example of using price as a kind of “get to the front of the line” card on a large scale. That being stated, both tiers must line up and wait in line for a long time to get a good seat relative to their tier.
ReplyDeletePerhaps on a smaller scale, I-Bucks could be used to escape the line, but students must still be members of their respective tier. This may still offer incentives to have philanthropy and still offer decent seats to all members of Orange Krush, regardless of whether or not they use I-Bucks.
I also really enjoyed your point on Orange Krush and how that can be used by students with Illinibucks. Like you mentioned, many students in my opinion would use their Illinibucks towards many sporting events aside from simply using it for registration. Like we talked about in class there are however two different types of vouchers that students already get when being in Orange krush, which they receive and determine by how much money one raises. Thus like you mentioned, the kids with the most money when using or trading Illinibucks would be the ones getting the better seats even if they did not raise the most amount of money. Doing this however could potentially take away the purpose of being a higher fundraising student because instead of devoting their time to raise so much money they could simply trade their Illinibucks to get better seats through orange krush. Also, this type of behavior on students part would cause University faculty to run into issues and consequences of seeing students do things like give students classnotes and such to get more Illinibucks, especially if the students start out with the same amount of bucks.
ReplyDelete