Fortunately I went home for the weekend where I could
recount and get some insight on all three experiences our prompt inquires
about. I am actually going to start by
talking about both of my parents who together have gone through all three
experiences.
My dad has
been through a few rounds in the business world, none of which have knocked him
out. My dad was laid off of work a
number of years back when the company he worked for was bought out. Given the
choice of relocating to Seattle, with three kids finishing up high school, or
staying in the area he chose to stay. I do not think he regrets his decision.
He had developed a strong resume and had the skills to open his own startup
consulting LLC. He used the time to go
back to get his MBA at University of Illinois. I have been able to see this
operation come full circle as he now has a job where he is no longer self
employed. For my example of someone who has carried a steady job I can look to
my mom who has worked in a relations position for Aspen Group for a few years.
It is a
fairly strange period of unemployment/ self employment. Because of the unemployment he used the
opportunity to improve himself by staying proactive and improving his
education. As I said he got a non self
employed job recently. You might think that his MBA made a significant
improvement in getting the job he desired, but it seems that he feels the pay
really is not that amazing or better in comparison to his old job. Where he did
have to adjust was in the position he wanted. He waited for a while for the
position he wanted to open up but he was told he was simply next in line for
when that person left. He appreciates the safety of money but he really seeks
after a level of challenge and responsibility that tests his skill set. Wages were fairly sticky throughout the time.
It is difficult to tell exactly what effect adding an MBA / self employment experience
had on the process but it obviously was a point of interest to employers.
Then
there are the self employed years my dad had. I do not know the actual impact
sticky wages had as there is much more to take into context. Starting up a
consulting LLC will have its own issues of its own, especially since it was in
its earliest stages. The downturn was difficult, but it did not seem to have a
huge affect on my dad’s business matters.
He was still able to find clients. Who knows? Maybe he could have had much
better business, but if you never experience good economic years, how do you
know what you are missing? It appeared
to be just a tougher startup process. I am sure that it had an affect here or there
that I have no idea occurred. (Dad-feel free to comment if you want)
Then there
is my mom who had a steady job. The downturn affected her differently as a
number of employees from her company were laid off. People in the company had
to absorb weaker bonuses than normal and cut down on some of the luxuries. She
is their main relations employee and has a valuable set of relationships with
important clients. Her company was
heavily affected, as they deal with construction. But if your work is valuable
enough, they will keep you. She has a
real drive and passion that make her a strong employee who is worth the money.
I want to be clear on terminology. Sticky wages mean what workers are paid doesn't vary much over the business cycle. If a company doesn't experience a decline in demand for it's products, then the lower revenues are either taken by other factors of production who get less or the owners get less.
ReplyDeleteSomebody who is self-employed is essentially the owner of their own business. They are a residual claimant. When product demand declines they earn less. I guess that was the situation for your dad when he was self-employed, though possibly he worked more hours as a partial offset, cutting his other costs where he could.
It's interesting that you brought up bonuses when talking about your mom. Their reduction because of the downtown is like a temporary wage cut. The way you wrote your last paragraph, it seemed that the company where she works did lay off other people. If so, having a mix of layoffs and pay cuts may seem sensible, though in econ classes we typically think there will be one or the other, but not both.
It seems as if your dad picked a perfect time to open up his own LLC considering how difficult the job search could have gotten if he was looking for employment within the past 5 or so years. It's very interesting to look how the recession affected different people in different positions, and in different fields as well. While some areas of work may have dropped off, others may have maintained a steady level of revenue, steady wages, and so on. The case with your mom and her company having to take on lesser bonuses and benefits and such happened to a lot of people nation wide. It was something that people had to just accept and adjust to, and it seems as if your mom made those adjustments with ease. An employee with value to the company in many different areas is almost irreplaceable, and it seems as if your mom fits the bill. Interesting post.
ReplyDeleteI also think it was a good idea for your father to open his own LLC, because it gave him the opportunity to recover at least part of his former wages. This is better than sitting around and waiting for the job, which can come years later. It's interesting that owning a company makes a person more sensitive to every client/ income generating product they have, because the loss of one will impact their wages, but that it is a better spot to be in compared to be laid off where you lose 100% of your former wages. In this sense, it is both more risky and more secure to own a company rather than work for one (assuming you are not losing money).
ReplyDelete